Archive for February, 2013

A path to quantum gravity?

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , on February 17, 2013 by quantummoxie

Joe Fitzsimons, Jonathan Jones and Vlatko Vedral just put out a fascinating and brilliant paper. I’ll be honest (no personal offense meant! 😀 ) and say that it is very much in the present style of writing physics and mathematics papers, which is to say as non-pedantic and jargon-laden as possible. This is a style I have come to dislike (think about this: we have freshman, non-science majors read Einstein’s original SR paper at Saint Anselm), but that is another story entirely.

Anyway, after some discussion with Joe about it I now see what they are getting at – and I think it offers a very intriguing potential path to follow in search of quantum gravity. It also seems to support my suspicion that time and space (or at least their connection via the metric) is emergent.

So here’s the basic argument. In quantum mechanics, density matrices are used to define quantum states that, in theory (depending on one’s interpretation), can extend throughout space. In other words, we use such matrices to represent what are usually spacelike separated measurement events. Joe, Jonathan, and Vlatko (henceforth FJV) ask if it might be possible to to extend these matrices in such a way as to cover a spread of time as well. In doing so they introduce the idea of a pseudo-density matrix (PDM). The PDM, like the usual density matrix, is positive semi-definite for spacelike separated events while it fails to be so for time like separated events (they don’t mention lightlike separations – in theory it should also fail to be positive semi-definite in this case). Intriguingly they actually present results of two qubit NMR experiments that support the results.

What really struck me is that they appear to be on the verge of being able to obtain the metric tensor of Minkowski space. In fact, Joe told me he had already recovered the signature which, given the results concerning the PDM, tells me they’ve already got the metric. In the signature convention (+,+,+,-), the metric tensor is indeed positive semi-definite for spacelike separations and not for timelike and lightlike separations.

The only thing I caution is that, though we like to proclaim the contrary (and FJV say it in their abstract), time and space are not the same in special relativity. If they were, time would have the same sign as space in the metric tensor (incidentally, Scott Aaronson agrees with me on this). In addition, if time and space were truly equal we would be able to go back in time.

Nevertheless, I think this is one of the most promising potential routes to quantum gravity that I’ve seen in years. It brings the “language” of quantum mechanics and relativity just a bit closer (something I’ve long thought about, but more in group theory terms) and it hints at the emergence of time (and maybe even space). It will be interesting to see where this leads.